Evidence-based review method
How JoinCheckup reviews a website
Everything we inspect, what each of our four labels means, how we ran our November 2026 field sample of 15 UK websites, and how we keep our guides and reports up to date.
Automation tools help businesses run subscription emails. JoinCheckup examines what a customer can actually see, understand and do on your website.
1. Exact list of what we check
For every Public Website Check (£99 launch price), a human reviewer visits your live public website as a first-time consumer—without logging in or asking for admin access—and checks the following public pages and elements:
- Home page claims: Headline prices, "from £X" promotions, contract-length slogans (such as "no contract" or "cancel anytime") and review or star-rating badges.
- Pricing and membership pages: Recurring price, billing frequency, minimum term, mandatory joining, induction, admin or delivery fees, and how optional add-ons are separated from compulsory charges.
- Public join and sign-up pages: Whether mandatory fees or minimum terms appear for the first time on the sign-up screen or contradict the headline pricing page.
- Free trial and introductory offer wording: Whether the site states clearly when a free or discounted trial ends, what the standard recurring price is, and how to stop before billing begins.
- Cancellation information visible before sign-up: Whether clear cancellation steps, notice periods, exit channels (online vs phone, email or in writing) and 14-day cooling-off wording appear on public FAQ or terms pages.
- Terms and conditions: Consistency between public marketing copy and written contract terms, including auto-renewal terms and blanket "no refund" statements.
- Reviews, star ratings and review policy: Whether star ratings or member testimonials are accompanied by a published review policy and clear attribution.
On the Website and Customer Journey Check (£249), we also inspect up to 10 screenshots you send us after payment—covering your final checkout total screen, your logged-in cancellation path, and your welcome, free-trial and renewal reminder emails.
2. The four labels and their definitions
We never invent a score out of 100, never issue a certificate or badge, and never make legal findings about a business. Every point in a report carries one of four plain, verifiable labels:
| Label | Definition |
|---|---|
| Found | Visible evidence was located on the reviewed public pages (or in the screenshots sent by the business). |
| Not found | The information was not found in the reviewed pages during the check. |
| Possible risk | A point that deserves attention, paired with the official GOV.UK or legislation.gov.uk source it relates to and a practical fix. |
| Needs evidence | The answer depends on something the business must show us (for example its checkout screen, logged-in cancellation process or renewal emails). |
Every finding records the exact page URL, the observed wording or screenshot, the label, the official source link and a practical fix, then groups all actions into Fix now (rules in force since April 2025), Fix before the subscription rules start, and Check internally.
3. Our November 2026 field sample of 15 websites (and its limits)
In a JoinCheckup sample of 15 UK subscription websites, 11 showed at least one visible issue when we re-checked each page by eye on 22 November 2026 (a small, non-random sample: it shows what we look for, not how common these issues are across the UK).
We publish this number carefully and transparently, along with how the sample was selected and what it cannot prove:
- How the 15 websites were chosen: In November 2026, we selected 15 publicly accessible UK consumer subscription and membership websites across independent gyms, fitness studios, online courses, consumer apps and subscription boxes—reflecting the two business segments JoinCheckup serves. We inspected only publicly visible pages without logging in or contacting the businesses, and we do not name any business from the sample.
- What counted as a visible issue: Observing at least one clear public-page gap such as a mandatory joining fee shown separately from the headline monthly price, "no contract" wording conflicting with a 12-month term at sign-up, a free trial without conversion timing or price, cancellation restricted to phone, email or writing, star ratings shown with no review policy, or a "cancel anytime" claim with no visible cancellation steps.
- Limits of the sample: Fifteen websites is a small, non-random observational sample, not a statistically representative survey of the entire UK market. It shows only that visible public-page issues appeared frequently in the sites we inspected at that point in time, and cannot be generalised into an industry-wide percentage. Our first pass used automated page summaries; on 22 November 2026 we re-checked every page by eye and counted only issues we could still see on the live page that day, which lowered the count from 13 to 11.
4. Official sources we use
Every guide and every finding in a JoinCheckup report links directly to primary UK government and statutory sources rather than secondary commentary:
- GOV.UK — Unfair commercial practices (CMA207) (drip pricing, unfair practices and direct CMA fining powers, in force since 6 April 2025)
- GOV.UK — Fake reviews guidance (in force since 6 April 2025)
- GOV.UK — Gold's Gym (UK) Limited enforcement case (Final Infringement Notice 29 September 2026; settlement published 14 October 2026)
- GOV.UK — Travel and leisure businesses investigated over pricing practices (18 November 2026)
- legislation.gov.uk — Draft Consumer Subscription Contracts (Cancellation and Information) Regulations 2026 (laid October 2026, expected from 1 January 2027)
- GOV.UK — Subscription contracts
- legislation.gov.uk — Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, Schedule 22, paragraph 9 (exclusions)
5. How we date and update content when rules change
Consumer rules evolve—in particular, the 2026 subscription regulations are still draft regulations awaiting Parliamentary approval. Every date-sensitive guide and the CMA enforcement tracker carries a visible "Last reviewed" date (currently 21 November 2026). When Parliament approves final regulations, when the CMA publishes updated guidance, or when new enforcement outcomes are published, we update our guides, note the new review date, and update the sources version cited on every new report. Every delivered report also records the exact date of the review and the exact version of official sources used on that date.
See this methodology in action: inspect our illustrative sample report, run a free 3-point check, or compare our fixed-price website checks.