In force now (since 6 April 2025): Under the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, fake reviews are banned and businesses must take reasonable steps against fake or misleading reviews (GOV.UK Fake reviews guidance). The CMA can fine businesses directly up to 10% of global turnover or £300,000, whichever is higher (GOV.UK CMA207). This guide is plain-English information, not legal advice.
1. Why star ratings and testimonials need attention now
Almost every independent gym, yoga studio, martial arts school, climbing centre, online course and subscription box displays customer praise on its website—a star rating in the hero section, a scrolling carousel of quotes, or an embedded review widget. Until recently, many small businesses copied a few positive comments onto their home page and never gave them another thought.
Since 6 April 2025, however, the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024 bans fake reviews and requires businesses that publish consumer reviews or review information to take reasonable steps to prevent and remove fake or misleading reviews. The GOV.UK Fake reviews guidance explains what businesses need to consider in practice, and the CMA holds direct fining powers of up to 10% of global turnover or £300,000, whichever is higher (GOV.UK Unfair commercial practices CMA207).
For small UK businesses, the issue is rarely buying fake reviews. Far more often, it is displaying star ratings or hand-picked quotes with no explanation of where they came from, no date, no review policy, and no clear process for handling negative feedback or checking that a reviewer was a genuine customer. Automation tools help businesses run subscription emails. JoinCheckup examines what a customer can actually see, understand and do on your website.
2. Common visible review gaps on small UK websites
In a JoinCheckup sample of 15 UK subscription websites, 11 showed at least one visible issue when we re-checked each page by eye on 22 November 2026 (a small, non-random sample: it shows what we look for, not how common these issues are across the UK). Across membership and subscription websites, we repeatedly notice four practical gaps around reviews and ratings:
- Star ratings with no review policy: A home page states "4.9 out of 5 stars" or displays five gold stars beneath the headline, but there is no review policy anywhere on the site explaining how reviews are collected, checked or moderated.
- Unexplained or outdated aggregate scores: A static graphic claims "Rated 5 stars by 200 members" without saying which platform the rating came from, whether it includes all reviews or only selected ones, or when the number was last checked.
- Cherry-picked testimonials presented like overall ratings: Publishing only hand-picked five-star quotes while suppressing genuine lower-rated comments can give a misleading impression if visitors are led to think they are viewing an overall picture of customer feedback.
- Incentivised reviews without clear disclosure: Offering free classes, merchandise, prize-draw entries or discounts in return for leaving a review without making clear when a review was incentivised—or worse, tying an incentive to leaving a positive rating.
3. What practical, reasonable steps look like for a small business
A single-site yoga studio or small subscription box does not need an enterprise moderation department. Reasonable steps should match the size of your business and the way you display reviews. Start with four straightforward habits:
1. Publish a plain-English review policy
Create a short, readable review policy page (or a clear section linked from your footer and next to your star rating block). A practical review policy answers five plain questions:
- Where the reviews and star ratings shown on your website come from (for example, direct customer submissions or a named third-party platform).
- How you invite customers to leave feedback, and a clear statement that you do not pay for positive reviews or write reviews yourselves.
- How you check that reviews submitted directly to your website come from real members or buyers.
- How you treat negative reviews—making clear that genuine critical reviews are not removed simply because they are negative, and listing the narrow reasons a review may be removed (such as spam, abusive language or proof it is not from a genuine customer).
- How anyone can report a review they believe is inaccurate or not genuine, with a working email address.
You can read a complete illustrative review policy on our sample report page.
2. Label third-party star ratings accurately
If your home page displays an average star score pulled from an external review platform, name the platform clearly and state when the figure was checked—or use a live embed rather than a frozen number copied three years ago. Never combine scores selectively or leave out platforms where your score is lower while presenting a single number as your overall rating.
3. Check how you ask for reviews
Inviting all members or subscribers to share honest feedback is good practice. Avoid inviting only customers you expect to give five stars, and never offer a discount, free month or gift in exchange for a positive review. If you run a neutral incentive (such as a prize draw open to honest feedback regardless of rating), keep clear records and disclose incentivised reviews plainly in line with the GOV.UK Fake reviews guidance.
4. Keep a lightweight internal check
When you add a quote directly to your website from an email, direct message or feedback form, keep a simple internal note confirming the customer's membership or order record and permission to publish. Review your published ratings periodically—for instance, once a quarter—so numbers stay accurate.
4. What if your reviews come from a booking or e-commerce widget?
Many gyms and studios use ClubRight, Clava, TeamUp, Momence, Glofox, Mindbody or Wix Pricing Plans, while subscription boxes and online courses often rely on Shopify, WooCommerce, Uscreen or Stripe alongside third-party review widgets. Using a review widget or membership platform does not by itself make your review presentation clear. You are still responsible for what appears on your own website—including any headline star summary you type into your hero banner, any testimonials you curate by hand, and having a visible review policy explaining how your business handles reviews.
Illustrative examples: vague display vs transparent review presentation
Small wording updates make a noticeable difference to how honest and clear your review section feels to a first-time visitor:
| Common pattern on small websites | Clearer, more transparent wording |
|---|---|
| "Rated 4.9 stars by our members" (static text with no source, no date and no review policy). | "4.9 out of 5 stars based on Google reviews (checked November 2026). Read our review policy." |
| Four glowing quotes on the join page with no indication of how reviews are gathered or moderated. | "Selected comments from current and past members. We invite honest feedback from all members and never remove genuine negative reviews simply because they are critical. See our review policy." |
| "Leave us a 5-star review to get a free guest pass!" | Avoid tying any reward to a positive rating. Invite honest feedback without requiring a favourable score, and disclose any neutral incentive clearly in line with GOV.UK guidance. |
Notice that none of these changes require expensive software or complex integrations. A short, honest review policy linked in your footer and next to your star ratings, paired with accurate attribution on external ratings and fair review-request habits inside your team, covers the practical basics a consumer actually sees.
If your gym, studio or subscription business is refreshing its website ahead of the expected 1 January 2027 subscription contract rules, updating your review section alongside your pricing and cancellation wording lets you address both April 2025 duties and upcoming subscription clarity in a single tidy pass.
5. A quick review check on your own pages
Walk through your home page, pricing page and footer and check:
- Do you show star ratings, review totals or member quotes anywhere on your public pages?
- If yes, is there a visible link to a review policy that a visitor can read in under two minutes?
- Does any static star rating state its source and date?
- If you copy quotes onto your site, can you verify internally that each quote came from a real customer and has not been altered to change its meaning?
- Do your staff and automated follow-up emails ask for honest feedback rather than specifically asking for five-star reviews?
6. How JoinCheckup reviews your ratings and review policy
Every JoinCheckup report inspects how star ratings, review counts and testimonials appear across your public pages. If you display ratings without a review policy, we flag the gap clearly with Not found or Possible risk, link directly to the GOV.UK Fake reviews guidance, place it under Fix now (rules in force since April 2025), and include a ready-to-adapt review policy text you can publish straight away. JoinCheckup is not a law firm and our reports are not legal advice.
Check your website for review and pricing gaps
Start with our free 3-point check on one public page, or order a complete Public Website Check delivered within 2 working days.
Read next: UK subscription contract rules (main guide) · Drip pricing and joining fees · Cancellation rules